What the SEC Proposed
The Securities and Exchange Commission on Friday issued a proposal aimed at the governance and funding model of the Consolidated Audit Trail, the system that records orders and trades across American equity and options markets. According to the agency, the proposal would rescind Rule 613 of Regulation NMS, the rule that established the audit trail and set out how it is built, operated and paid for.
The SEC framed the action as a response to inefficiencies in the current structure. In its summary, the Commission said the proposal addresses problems in both how the CAT is governed and how it is funded. The agency did not, in the material released, attach a dollar figure to those inefficiencies or describe a replacement framework in detail.
What the proposal does is open a formal process. A proposal is not a final rule. It is a step that invites public comment, and the Commission can revise, narrow or abandon it before anything takes effect. Until a final rule is adopted, Rule 613 remains in place and the CAT continues to operate under its existing arrangements.
What the Consolidated Audit Trail Actually Does
To understand why rescinding Rule 613 is a significant step, it helps to understand what the CAT is for. The system was set up after the 2010 flash crash, when regulators found they could not quickly reconstruct what had happened across the many venues where US stocks trade. At the time, each exchange kept its own records, and piecing together a single order's path across multiple markets was slow and sometimes impossible.
The CAT was designed to fix that. It is a single, centralized database that receives order and trade data from broker-dealers and exchanges, tagged with a unique identifier for each market participant. In practical terms, it lets the SEC and self-regulatory organizations reconstruct the life of an order from the moment a customer places it to the moment it executes, cancels or expires, even when that order touches several trading venues.
That capability matters for enforcement. When the agency investigates manipulation, insider trading or unusual trading patterns around news, the audit trail is one of the primary tools for identifying who did what and when. It also supports market reconstruction after disruptions, when regulators need to understand how a sudden move unfolded.
Why Governance and Funding Are the Flashpoints
The CAT is unusual among market utilities in that it is operated by a private entity under an SEC-approved plan, while the data flowing into it comes from the industry it monitors. That structure has produced years of friction over two questions: who sits on the body that runs the system, and who pays for it.
On governance, the debate has centered on how much influence broker-dealers and exchanges have over the plan's operating committee relative to regulators and the public. On funding, the dispute has been about how the operating costs are allocated across the firms that must report data. Operating a database of this scale is expensive, and the firms required to feed it have argued about their share of the bill.
Rule 613 is the anchor for both arrangements. It is the rule that directed the creation of the CAT and that underpins the plan governing its operation. Rescinding it would remove that anchor, which is why the proposal is more than a technical housekeeping change. The SEC's stated rationale is that the current model is inefficient, but the practical effect of removing the rule would depend entirely on what the Commission puts in its place.
What It Means for American Investors and Firms
For individual investors, the CAT is invisible. It does not appear on a brokerage statement and does not change how an order is routed or priced. Its relevance is indirect: it is part of the infrastructure that supports market surveillance and enforcement, and the confidence that comes with knowing trading activity can be reconstructed after the fact.
For brokerage firms, the implications are more concrete. Firms that report data into the CAT bear compliance costs, and any restructuring of the funding model could shift how those costs are distributed. Firms also build internal systems around the reporting requirements, and a change to the underlying rule could eventually require changes to those systems, though nothing changes on that front while the proposal is pending.
For exchanges and other market participants involved in the plan's governance, the proposal opens a question about who will hold decision-making authority over the system going forward.
The Comment Process and What Comes Next
The proposal now enters the public comment stage, where firms, trade groups and other interested parties can submit views on whether rescinding Rule 613 is the right approach and what should replace the current arrangements. That record typically shapes how a final rule is drafted, and it is common for proposals to change substantially before adoption.
Readers should treat this as the opening of a process rather than a completed change. The SEC has said it is targeting inefficiencies in governance and funding. It has not, in the material released, said what structure would follow if Rule 613 is rescinded, and the agency has not published a timeline for a final decision.
The practical takeaway is that the rule underpinning the country's central record of trading activity is now formally under review. The CAT itself continues to operate, the reporting obligations on firms remain in force, and the surveillance capability the system provides is unchanged for now. What is in play is the framework around it: who runs the audit trail, and who pays for it.
Source: SEC
This article is for information only and is not investment advice, a recommendation, or an offer to buy or sell any security. Figures are sourced from third-party market data providers and may be delayed. Do your own research before investing.
